Friday, July 27, 2012

The Diabetic Church

Coptic Christians in Egypt
From an article on persecution of the church in Egypt
In my mind today, the picture I have is a church in a diabetic coma that has gorged itself on the sweets of affluence, materialism, and the idolatry of worshipping the materialistic world. That diabetic coma is now life threatening. We as a church are at the point of death – not the church in the Middle East. We are the ones who can no longer rouse ourselves to even pray for an hour on behalf of things that God would have us pray for.
I like this image. I think he could carry the analogy even further. One of the things that can happen to diabetics is they are unable to feel injuries to some parts of their bodies. They can end up with a toe or a foot amputated because they had an injury and they didn't respond correctly. Diabetics are told not to wear open-toed shoes because small injuries tend to become big problems due to the lack of circulation.

We are seeing that kind of non-response in the body of Christ. Christians are being attacked in many parts of the world. When healthy the body should react. The nerves should feel the pain. The circulatory system should send a bunch of stuff to heal the foot and fight infection. But right now the Christian nervous system is barely noticing the persecution. We are not sending help in any way. We don't seem too concerned that we might lose a toe. 

Moeller thinks this is tied to too much sugar in the church's diet over the long term. Materialism is one problem. Another might be too much concern over getting the pews filled on Sunday morning and not enough about what being the Kingdom of God looks like. Whatever the issue, the lack of response by Christians in the west is cause for concern. Certainly a concern for Christians in those parts of the world but also a concern for the church here that fails to respond to such an obvious crisis. 
One guy who has been talking about this is John Allen.


The second link contains this announcement.
The U.S. bishops, in collaboration with the Catholic University of America and Catholic Relief Services, are planning to hold a conference titled "International Religious Freedom: An Imperative for Peace and the Common Good" on Sept. 12 in Washington. Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York will deliver the opening address, and the Vatican's top diplomat, French Archbishop Dominique Mamberti, has been invited to give the closing speech.

Thursday, July 26, 2012

Logic and Sex

Can a person approach sex purely logically? That is what those who reject most sexual ethics claim to be doing. Are they really? Freud warned of the dangers of repressing sexual desire. Even in scripture St Paul warns virgins it is better to marry than to burn with passion. But is sexual repression really the biggest problem in today's world? Should we be so scared of being repressed that we get rid of all the rules? Is that logically the smart thing to do? Just do whatever our hormones push us to do? It can't be wrong if it feels right?

If that is true then logically you would expect that the people who live that way would be the happiest people out there. We have a pretty good sample size. In today's world there a lot of people who have lived that lifestyle or something very close to it for a time. Did that lead to happiness? Not exactly. People go a lot of directions from there. Some go into more deviant sexual behavior. Some find someone they want to marry and discover they are not prepared for a monogamous relationship. Some stop having sex for a while and reflect on what it all means. Some try and stop and discover they can't. The end up addicted to sex or porn. The stories go a lot of different directions but nobody seems to get to the top of this mountain and finds a lasting peace and joy. They all move on.

Of course those are just the survivors. There are also many who got hurt on the way to the top of that mountain. The ones who were scared by abuse and betrayal. The ones that suffer from post-abortion trauma. People who never fully embraced the promiscuous life but dabbled in it long enough to get deeply wounded.

So what is the logical thing to do with this data? If you know this field has many land mines. You know the powers of reasoning that you normally count on can be badly influenced by your hormones. You don't trust traditional sexual morality. So what is the most prudent thing to do? If the person involved is not you but your son or daughter then it becomes easier to see. The smart thing is to err on the side of safety. Go slow. Try and find a trustworthy path and stick to it.

Somehow that is not what is done in the name of logic and reason. People just assert that if they can't see a land mine then the logical thing to do is to assume there is none there. Even if the land mines in question are not expected to be visible. Even if there are people warning you this field is full of land mines.

I can understand when young people are impetuous when it comes to sex. They experience love for the first time and they are sure it is the greatest love the world has ever known. In some ways it is. What I don't understand is the idea that just following your desires into pornography and promiscuity is somehow logical.  That dismissing the wisdom of many generations of human experience is somehow smart. That doing what everyone else seems to be doing without asking whether you want the result everyone else is getting is somehow reasonable.

There was a time when we recognized a lack of sexual self control as contrary to reason. Now we just declare it to be smart. Never mind how many abortions, how many divorces, how many rapes, how much depression, etc. It can't be stupid because it is common. So it becomes the wisdom of the age. What you follow if you want to have a life like your peers. Completely unremarkable. No guarantees of happy life but you are much more likely to have a boring one. The irony is that using sex to fight boredom is one of the major errors of our times. Not only do we not get what sex is meant to point us to but we end up bored anyway.

Monday, July 23, 2012

How Science Loses God

God is simple. That does not mean He is easy to understand. It means He cannot be subdivided. His love is His justice is His mercy is His wisdom is His providence ... Humans love to subdivide. Science tends to understand things by breaking them into component parts. Then they try understand each part and then understand the relationships between the parts. You can learn a lot about something that way. You can lose a lot too. One of the things you are likely to lose is God. You can see God in a sunset. If you analyze all the rays of light one by one you might still see some beauty there but you will lose the sunset.

We all know that science cannot find God. The truth is worse. If we are not careful science will lose God. They say the devil is in the details. That is not completely true but God is much easier to see in the big picture. When we consider all aspects of all of creation for all of history. We can't do that of course because we can't understand God but our tendency is to do the opposite. To learn more and more about less and less. Small is comfortable.

Peter Kreeft calls this reductionism.
Science's reductionistic method fails to see cosmic love. Modern science requires the use of the simplest possible explanation. This is the principle called "Occam's Razor." The modern mind always tends to reduce the greater to the lesser rather than seeing the lesser as reflecting the greater. It thinks of human love as only complex animal instinct, or even complex electrochemical attraction, rather than thinking of these subhuman attractions as love on a lesser level. Premodern thought saw lust as confused love. Modern thought sees love as rationalized lust. This is reductionism.
Just separating love and lust is a big enough problem. People also separate sex and procreation. They separate marriage and sex.  By analyzing the parts rather than the whole we can distort things badly. What is worse we don't see the potential that we might miss something. We not only end up wrong but wrong while being very sure we are right. We sum the parts and when we are told the whole is greater than that we check our sums and declare that it can't be.

Biblical interpretation has this danger as well. We tend to focus on one text at a time. Then we try and build a systematic theology. The word of God is scripture, tradition, and the magisterium. That is "word" singular. God is not giving us a bunch of independent revelations. He gave us one word. The Word was with God and the Word was God. But if God cannot be subdivided then how can we subdivide the Word? If we do we have lost God because God cannot be subdivided.

We are not meant to live in a small world we can understand. That is the world of pettiness and sin. A world closed in on itself. We are called to live in a world that we cannot possibly understand or control. That is the nature of God. If we will but trust and obey we can live that large and get a glimpse of glory. If we insist on living what we understand then we will always analyze God out of our life. We may not become explicit atheists but our image of God will be so tame we may as well be.

Saturday, July 21, 2012

Atheism And Evolution

Joe Heschmeyer at Shameless Popery talks about how evolution does not disprove Christianity. Then he makes a quick point that the evidence is actually the other way.
In fact, the entire process of evolution points to an ultimate beginning, and thus, to a Creator.  So the entire debate over evolution is worse than a red herring, because it starts from the completely inaccurate assumption that if evolution is true, religion is false (and vice versa).  In fact, the opposite is true: if everything in time and space originated at a single point, and grew and developed and evolved, tracing the line backwards gets you to a place where a Timeless, Spaceless Cause is necessary to set the whole chain in motion... that is, evolution should be considered a proof for our Eternal, Immaterial God, rather than against Him.
This is kind of along the lines of St Thomas Aquinas. Causality points to an uncaused cause. I am not sure you need evolution to prove causality so it does not really add anything logically but the diagrams you draw when showing how one species led to another seem to cry out for an ultimate source. So it shows intuitively what St Thomas shows logically. But you still need St Thomas to show what sort of properties this uncaused cause has. That it really is God-like and we are not just filling a scientific gap with God.

Atheist allow themselves any gap in their theory, any huge question they don't have an answer to. They will mock you as believing in "god of the gaps" if you suggest the massive holes in atheism are a reason to reject it. There is a point that neither atheism nor Christianity claims to know everything. It is hard to imagine a problem with either system that cannot be covered over with an appeal to some answer we don't know and may never know.  So both theism and atheism are unfalsifiable. Christianity is somewhat falsifiable. You could find the body of Jesus. Catholicism is very falsifiable. The papacy could to cease to exists. The church could teach a contradiction. In fact, if Catholicism was not true the probability that it would have been falsified by now is about 100%.

Anyway, after declaring atheism to be unfalsifiable I shall try and falsify it. I won't succeed in an absolute sense but I do think evolution gives us some good reasons to reject atheism. Atheism teaches that some of the basic desires of the human person are not based on reality. We want to believe in goodness. We want to believe life has meaning. We want to believe in life after death. We want to believe in justice, good deeds will be rewarded and bad deeds will be punished. Atheists want to believe these things too. They just tell us our desire to believe these things is not evidence that they are true. That is not really accurate. It is at least possible that our desires might be pointing to a truth. It could be we have a spiritual sense. Just like we have eyes to tell us about the world of light and ears to tell us about the world of sound we might have some sense to tell us about the spiritual world. That can't be logically excluded.

The other choice that atheists assume is right is that our minds are defective rather than perceptive. Rather than perceiving a truth they are telling us a lie. But that is where evolution comes in. Evolution expects biological traits to make some sense. Humans having a perceptive brain would fit. Humans having a defective brains does not really fit. Simple defects might happen but elaborate traits are supposed to have purposes. It becomes ironic because atheists love to go on and on about how terrible religion is and how superior atheism is to any religion but if that is really true then evolution should have given us atheism. It is certainly simpler and would be better.

Atheists can dig themselves in deeper if they want. They can argue that evolution should not be expected to produce a human mind ordered towards truth. That a mind that lies to us has survival advantages and that is what we would expect. There are two problems with that. One is that atheists tend to do their thinking with a human mind. If what comes out of such a mind is inherently untrustworthy then why should we listen to them?

The second problem is our minds value truth. We can't choose to believe something we know is false. So evolution has to produce a mind that loves truth yet also loves falsehood. Those kinds of minds need to be somehow superior to those that don't invent any supernatural narrative at all.

Isn't this beautiful? Try to imagine an atheist who has a teensy problem with arrogance. I know you probably never ran into any that are like that but I have encountered a few. Then imagine them having to show why ancient atheists were inferior to ancient theists. That atheists and theists had this long term battle for survival and the theists won. Maybe instead of referring to themselves as brights they should refer to themselves as losers to help make this scenario seem more reasonable.

Anyway, someone could just say science will someday find great answers to all these problems. But the point is evolution is actually on the side of the theists. Sure it causes problems for fundamentalist Christians who are a small minority of theists that happen to be overrepresented in present day US. Still overall it does not make atheism more reasonable. The causality issues it seems to solve are just pushed back and it creates a whole new set of questions.

Friday, July 20, 2012

What Liberal Christianity Is Not

Ross Douthat has a good follow up article on liberal Christianity. He is responding to a critique by Steve Holmes. Holmes sees liberal Christianity as a response to a crisis of truth.
So, as a broad approximation, liberal Christianity is Christianity that is acutely alive to the challenges to belief coming from modern philosophy. Kant’s denial of knowledge of the noumenal realm apparently made traditional accounts of revelation impossible, and the more-or-less simultaneous rise of Biblical criticism made traditional accounts of revelation profoundly precarious even if possible.
So we see a philosophical challenge that we might call modern skepticism. How can we know anything beyond the senses with certainty? Anything about God, anything about right or wrong, anything about how things are meant to be? We also have a biblical challenge. Lots of historical and linguistic research was shedding new light on the bible and questioning it from new angles. So having the bible as the foundation of your world and life view was not working that well.

One reaction to this was fundamentalism. It is actually only a few centuries old. It puts the focus on faith. Just reject all the research you don't like. Faith becomes a trump card that can defeat any rational objection. A rejection of evolution in favor of a literal interpretation of Genesis was a classic example. Dismissing scientific arguments based a a verse of scripture became a virtue.
Liberal Christianity didn't go there. Where it did go is unclear. Holmes said it based itself on "shared religious experience" and thought Schleiermacher was the key thinker. That strikes me as kind of lame. Every community has shared experience, some of it good and some of it bad. But that hardly counts as a basis for a religion. For a club maybe but not a religion.

What makes liberal Christianity hard to define is the lack of a foundation. It mostly believes in scripture. It mostly believes in reason. It tries to focus on action rather than theology. This is because its theology is either borrowed from the culture with religious language injected or it is a critique of fundamentalism. It really does not have a basis for its own theology.

So Douthat was being kind in just identifying liberal Christians as those who do a lot of social action. That is how they like to be thought of because that is when they are at their best. But fundamentalists and Catholics do social action as well. Liberal Christianity really can only be defined negatively. It is the faith without content. What CS Lewis called "men without chests."

Talking about fundamentalism and liberalism, I should not neglect to mention that Catholicism has the best of both worlds. That is it has infallible doctrine but no doctrine contradicted by science. We have help. The Holy Spirit keeps us from defining falsehood as dogma. Biblical criticism is easier for us to deal with because the bible is not the foundation of the Church. Again we had help. Jesus cleverly built the church on the rock of Peter and not on the scriptures as its basic foundation. So the successor of Peter can define how scripture is to be read. Pope Benedict XVI has said that his Jesus of Nazareth books are, in part, an example to all Christians on how to do proper exegesis, how to use historical criticism, how to avoid hyper-skepticism, how to incorporate the unity of the whole of scripture and tradition, etc.

Thursday, July 19, 2012

How Is Sin And Hell Be Good News?

One of the big objections to talking about sin when we evangelize is the idea that the gospel is supposed to be good news. How can we say that Jesus' arrival is cause for great joy and at the same time say that unless they repent they are going to spend eternity in hell? One answer to that is because you were already in that situation before Jesus arrived. He gives you a way out. The trouble is many moderns don't feel that way. They don't have this sense that they are evil and deserving of great punishment. A few might but the great majority feel they are pretty much OK.

But why do people feel they are OK? What is the standard they are applying to themselves? Most people feel that if they are generally nice, tolerant and polite then they are fine. When they fail to meet even that standard if they have a good reason they still think they are fine. They think of themselves as social animals. Mostly self-absorbed but occasionally doing something out of empathy. Most of their relationships fill their own needs and are not really focused on the good of the other person. Sex is often a game rather than a gift. They don't feel particularly bad about any of that.

What evangelism needs to do is spark a desire for more. I say spark because the human heart naturally wants to burst into flame with this desire. We know we are meant for self-sacrificial love. We should have great courage and wisdom. There should be hope for an eternal rest in peace when we die. There should be profound truths about life that we can learn. We know we are meant to be saints. We just can't be satisfied with anything less. Evangelism is about awakening that knowledge in people's hearts.

When we do that then people will get that there is something deeply wrong with the way they are living their life. That hell is not just something Christians use to scare gullible people. Hell is just where this self-absorbed lifestyle leads. It logically should lead there. When St Paul calls people "senseless, faithless, heartless, ruthless" (Rom 1:31) they see themselves in that and get that that road has to lead to something bad. 

So the good news of God's love for us and the bad news of our sin turn out to be 2 sides of the same coin. When we know we are meant to partake in the divine nature then our temptation to think of ourselves as animals is deeply offensive. Yet we still fall into it. That sends us to God begging for His grace.

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Can Christianity Be Saved?

Can Christianity be saved? Diana Butler Bass asks this question on responding to Ross Douthat's NY Times column called: "Can Liberal Christianity be Saved?" She has a point. Back in the 1960's liberal churches were the only one losing members but that is changing.
That was 1972. Forty years later, in 2012, liberal churches are not the only ones declining. It is true that progressive religious bodies started to decline in the 1960s. However, conservative denominations are now experiencing the same. For example, the Southern Baptist Convention, one of America's most conservative churches, has for a dozen years struggled with membership loss and overall erosion in programming, staffing, and budgets. Many smaller conservative denominations, such as the Missouri Synod Lutherans, are under pressure by loss.
So we have all of Christianity under threat. Quite frankly many have already assumed the disease is terminal. People expect their children will be less religious than they are. That politics will consistently move in a direction that respects religion less and less. They have bought into the idea that religion is going down and if you cling to it too tightly you will go down with it.

But are they right? Are even the strongest churches in America going to go the way of the Episcopalian church today? I think it will get a lot worse before it gets better. I don't think protestantism is strong enough to withstand modern secularism. All of protestantism is really liberal. It changes with the culture. Evangelicalism has created a subculture that has protected it for a while but it is just delaying the process. The subculture is holding off liberal doctrines for a few decades but that is a very short time in the life of the church.

So what is the answer? Ms Bass seems to feel we should just embrace liberalism as inevitable. She puts a lot of hope in a few creative leaders that are generating some excitement. There will always be those but they don't last. Humanly speaking we have no hope.

I am reminded of something Fr Barron said in the Catholicism series. That Israel expected the Messiah to gather the scattered tribes. That Israel was intended to unify the whole world and bring them to God but instead Israel itself had become divided and really a barrier to people embracing the Jewish faith. The solution was Jesus. He called Jews from all these scattered tribes to Himself or more precisely to His Church. Those that did not follow were destroyed in 70 AD.

I see the solution here being similar. The divisions among Christians are at the root of our weakness. We have become a barrier to Christ. The solution is to embrace Jesus through His church. Like the first Pentecost we need Peter to stand up and say we are not drunk but we are following Jesus in a way that seems strange to you. Then we need the multitude from all over to be grief stricken at the way they have treated the body of Christ. It is beginning to happen. As the problems with protestantism become more obvious we will see more and more of it.