Wednesday, June 30, 2010

Dialogue with Tim Prussic

Copied from here:
I am certain that you missed my point: God’s word, the Bible, is complete and unchanging. It is authoritative, as it is expired by God (2 Tim 3:16). Each part is in agreement, and it is subject to and interpreted by itself. The gospels are subject to Paul’s epistles and Paul’s epistles subject to the gospels. On a subjective level, we must interpret the word, to be sure. The objective authority resides in the standard, the deposit of divine revelation, which (unlike the church) has not changed. You want, it seems, to apply the attribute of the divine word to the church. But God’s written word is one thing and God’s church another. God’s word is infallible and inerrant, but the word NEVER predicates that to the church in the way that you so easily do.

I don’t doubt I am not understanding you. You say the bible is complete. That is your belief. I think you are missing a few books. Be that as it may, it makes by question about which section is subordinate nonsensical. The same can be said about scripture and the church. If they are 2 parts of the complete word of God the question becomes nonsense. I am not sure if you are aware but Catholics say the Word of God consists of scripture, tradition, and the magisterium. When you say “the church” I assume you mean tradition and the magisterium. So those are part of “the deposit of divine revelation”. Does it change? It does grow. But many elements of tradition, for example the statements of the councils, cannot change.

Does the bible indicate the church will be in some sense infallible? Mt 18:17 says, “If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if he refuses to listen even to the church, treat him as you would a pagan or a tax collector.” Does it sound like Jesus expects the church to get the wrong answer?

As to avoiding other brother by division, it’s simply not so. I disagree with, say, a charismatic brother and choose not to worship at that local body, but I affirm that we are brothers. I have had scores of conversations, meals, beers, whatnot with my charismatic brethren. Protestantism has a wide variety of diversity in it, to be sure. Catholicism has no less of a variety of diversity in it, though. I think we’re more honest about our differences, as we find our unity in Christ, not in a visible hierarchy. Do you, Randy, work closely with the homosexuals in the Roman communion? I doubt it. How about (less offensively) the charismatics in the Roman communion?

Having “conversations, meals, beers, whatnot” with a few members of a community is not unity. It is affinity. We can’t have affinity with every believer in Christ. We are commanded to have unity with them. It is not hard to figure out. It means doctrine. It means sacraments. It means governance. Saying you find unity in Christ sounds nice but it means nothing. I can be the biggest schismatic and still say we have unity in Christ. It turns the command into empty words by simply ignoring what the words mean. This is the problem with using scripture as the final authority. It is too easy to make the word of God your plaything.

Actually I am pretty charismatic. I used to be much more so in my younger years. The charismatic Catholics were the first ones I fellowshipped with long before I dreamed of converting. As far as homosexuals go. I do get those questions in prison ministry. Most homosexual Catholics stay in the closet unless they are planning to leave the church. They just live as singles. We have many of those in my parish. I don’t ask if they experience same-sex attraction. I dealt with it a lot when I was in youth ministry but that was a few years ago.

With the manifest diversity in your communion, I think this applies equally to the RCC:

The other problem with your solution is that nobody arrives at truth. Everybody agrees to disagree and the faithful are basically told their leadership has no clue what the gospel of Christ actually is. They can follow you or they can follow the [magisterium -TP]. But what if they want to follow God? Then they are on their own.

No, the orthodox position is clear even when there is widespread dissent. There is no need to wonder whether contraception is immoral. The number of people committing the sin or condoning the sin does not make it any less a sin. The magisterium makes clear God’s revelation. So if they want to follow God they can. In fact, the solid stand of the bishops and the pope on issues like that is quite remarkable in the face of widespread dissent. So your point about “manifest diversity” is manifestly false.

Liar, Lunatic, Lord, or Legend

CS Lewis has the most famous version of this argument in Mere Christianity. Forms of it go way back but it is essentially asking a person to look at Jesus and take seriously His claims. Lewis didn't list the legend option among his choices but many modern people think it belongs. Certainly Mohammad went there. He changed the Jesus story to make it more acceptable to him. Jesus was a good man and not God. His claims to be God were just legend along with the crucifixion. Sounds like another possibility.

If you think about it, this ends up being an extension of the liar or lunatic options. If the Jesus story is largely false then where did it start? Remember Christianity spread very far, very fast. Certainly by the time we have St Clement of Rome and St Ignatius of Antioch the story of Jesus is well known. The book of Acts was almost certainly written before the death of St Peter and St Paul sometime in the 60's. Luke was written before that. Likely Matthew and/or Mark was written before that. So this legend needs to have been manufactured just a few years after the death of Jesus. It is the only way you don't have to have thousands of people involved. But a legend that is created that quick is not a legend. It is really a lie.

So what we are talking about is the apostles lying or the apostles being lunatics. That is quite a stretch given how impressive they were and how much they were willing to sacrifice. But it becomes an even bigger stretch when you think about St Paul. The 12 could have been bamboozled by Jesus. That would make Jesus a liar or a lunatic but you can imagine it. But Paul never met Jesus until after the resurrection. Is he lying about the road to Damascus story. What is his motive? What the legend option does is essentially moves the liar or lunatic option down to the apostles. But now you don't have one liar or lunatic.

The story of Jesus is not like the legend of King Aurthur. A bunch of stories that happened at some ill defined and poorly documented point in history. We have evidence of many people close in time to Jesus changing their lives in a serious way because they believed this story. The documents are amazing. There simply are no historical documents as frequently and as accurately copied as the New Testament. You can say they are false but you have to answer why such falsehoods were told and why they were so widely believed.

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Crusades and Evangelism

I wonder about the Crusades. What to make of them. The first crusade seemed to have the hand of God on it. It succeeded because of several supernatural interventions. It was a miracle. But after that things went bad. There were 7 more crusades and none of them were entirely successful. Most of them were complete failures. So what are we to learn?

For one thing, if God does something once it does not mean He will do it again. Today's reading reminded me of that. God save Paul from the mouth of the lion. Great. But many Christians were send to the lions and not saved. Sometimes God does miracles to save us from suffering and death. More often He does not. If God prevents the first crusade from failing it does not mean they all enjoy the same. God can and did let them get destroyed.

I do wonder what the Christians were supposed to do after the first crusade. If you accept that God wanted it to happen then what should they have done after winning? My thinking was to focus less on building fortifications and more on evangelizing the Muslims. They were in an exposed position. They had a few decades of safety when the Muslims were divided. But they had nowhere near enough soldiers to defend such a big territory. So what did they do? They essentially did nothing assuming that God would protect them from any attack. They built some fortresses and created some orders of knights. But they Christian faith did not really get re-established in the area.

If they had seen the conquest of Jerusalem as the beginning of the process of making these Christian nations rather than the end of the process there may have been a different outcome. A few centuries earlier they evangelized France and Germany. They seemed to have forgotten how to do that. Christianity should grow. At that time Islam was growing but Christianity was not. It seemed like Christians were copying Muslim tactics and trying to grow by pure military power. Might makes right. But you can't use Muslim tactics to defeat the Muslim faith. You need to show how Christianity has a better story to tell.

The other think they needed to do was patch up their differences with Eastern Christians. By this time they were schismatic. The first crusade was undertaken to prevent the fall of Constantinople. But again, a military victory had the potential to lead to better relations but it didn't happen. The crusader states relied completely on western powers to protect them. But the logistics of moving soldiers from England, France, and Germany all the way to Jerusalem was one of the key reasons for the failure of many crusades. They needed allies that were closer and the Eastern Christians were the obvious choice. But often the crusaders ended up fighting the Eastern Christians as well as the Muslims.

Anyway, things got quite ugly. But the question of how to deal with an aggressive religious group like the Muslims of that time is a hard one. If we didn't fight them and eventually win they would just take over everything. But at what point do we say enough is enough? We have seen a few similar quandaries with other aggressive movements.

The Papacy and History

Yesterday's post was actually a sidetrack from what I wanted to write about. So I shall try again. The comment I wanted to focus on in terms of development of doctrine is something a protestant church history professor said. I don't remember his name or the exact quote but it was along the lines of the pope having an amazing ability to be on the right side of every heresy. One of the themes of church history is a string of heretical ideas. Protestants accept these as heresies. They don't think the Monophysites or the Nestorians had it right. So this guy was remarking how important it was that none of these heresies were embraced by the pope of the day. That would have been a disaster. He even went so far as to call that providential. That is that the grace of God was helping the pope get on the right side of one controversy after another.

What he is saying is that the catholic method of arriving at doctrinal truth worked. It worked when you would not expect human effort to work. That is a hard thing for many to grasp. Protestants agree with the answers the popes arrived at so that helps. Often they just see arriving at the right answer as being quite easy. Just open your bible and there it is. So they don't see it as remarkable that the papacy did not lead the whole church into any of these heresies. This is why you need to be deep in history.

Heresies don't last unless there is some reason why people believe them. Why would those reasons not apply to the pope as much as to anyone else? There were some human reasons. The pope often has an outsiders perspective. He often has better understanding of the tradition of the church. But that has been true of many protestant leaders and many of them have fallen for false teaching anyway. If there is anything 500 years of protestantism has taught us is how easily a church can go wrong. There is a lot of talk about 30,000 existing protestant denominations. The reality is there are many more that no longer exist. They all had leaders that tried to follow the bible. It isn't that easy.

Then there is the point where one must notice that the empirical evidence is not only remarkable but it is exactly the kind of remarkable evidence you would expect if what the Catholic church teaches about the papacy is true. Being grateful for God keeping His church from error in the past is good. But thinking about how God has done that is important because we know God is consistent. He is not going to be faithful to a principle for many centuries and then abandon it.

Monday, June 28, 2010

Development Overview

Getting back to development of doctrine, we have seen that it is possible to argue the believability of Israel as God's chosen nation by looking at the religious and moral history of Israel and comparing it to that of other nations at that time. We have seen that the difference between protestant Christianity and historical Christianity is apparent on so many issues that protestants can't really think about history too often or too deeply.

But Newman took it a step further. He tried to show Catholicism did not suffer from the same problem. That is hard to do. First of all, he is trying to prove a negative. He is arguing something does not exist. Secondly, he is trying to evaluate the logical flow of doctrine for consistency independently of whether they are true or not. That is almost impossible for most people to do. They get so powerfully influenced by whether they believe or disbelieve the doctrine itself they cannot honestly evaluate whether their was development or corruption. Newman tries to help by introducing some structure into the process. But if people want to arrive at a certain answer they generally can. The question is whether they can put aside their personal agendas long enough to hear God speak.

Perhaps an example is useful. One instance of development in the world of science was the move from the theory of the planets orbiting the earth in circular orbits to the planets orbiting the sun in elliptical orbits. Now if you wanted to argue this was a corruption you could. An ellipse is not a circle. So the old theory was false. The orbits are almost circular but they are not. So you could see an approximation being replaced by a better approximation. But if you didn't want to see that you could see a false theory being replaced by a true one.

So if you understand how much history there is. How many doctrinal categories and how many changes that occurred. Then you think about how each one of these is going to be a struggle to be objective because every person is going to come to the matter with a ton of baggage on all of them. Can a protestant assess the development of the papacy or the Marian dogmas without being overwhelmed by what his tradition has taught him about these matters? For me it took time. Ideas that seem absolutely obvious to me now took me years to arrive at.

It is hard work but it is worth it. I think once you get Newman's concept this is the closest thing to absolute proof of the truth of Christianity. Newman understood that his analysis would be a strong argument for Catholicism or atheism. The good new is the consistency of Catholicism is a powerful evidence in favor of a supernatural power being behind the Catholic church. It is something so far beyond what humans are capable of. Logically it could be an evil supernatural power but that seems like a stretch. Even if you are tempted to believe that you can apply Pascal's wager and discern there is no good reason to believe that.

Development of Doctrine and Theology of the Body are two ideas so amazing that anyone who understands them will become Catholic. The trouble is they are hard to understand. We have many biases around sex and religion. They are like those old 3D pictures you had stare at for a while before you could see anything. Then you saw it and it was like Wow! They are like that but you need to contemplate them a lot longer.

Friday, June 25, 2010

Is God Ignorable?

A while back I read this post suggesting God is ignorable. Jennifer id on to something but I think it is not quite that simple. The trouble is we can't ignore God forever. Eventually the question of God comes back. So in some ways He is the only one who isn't ignorable. But God never forces us to encounter Him either. He always invites but never compels. So he is ignorable in the sense that we always have a rational out. If we want to say No we can.

But then there are the times we try and get close to Him. That is always a struggle. Adoration is amazing that way. Both rewarding and frustrating. As a protestant you get worked up with powerful music and eloquent speakers. I could feel close to God pretty easily. But was I really close? It could have been human stimulation. Adoration is just silence. A whole hour of silence. You experience God more deeply but you desire more.

I guess that is a big difference. With the charismatic worship experience you never really feel inadequate. The adrenalin is flowing and you feel like you are on top of the world. Long term you feel like there must be more to Christianity than feeling that high over and over. But on the night it is satisfying.

Adoration often has me hungrier for God when I leave then I was when I came. Why is it so hard? Ignorable? Sure. I know by faith that He is there but only by faith. There is something in me that thinks God should give me more proof. But faith is not just for the neophytes. Faith is not strengthened by eliminating the need for faith. It is like lifting weights. We get stronger by making the bar heavier. So the more we desire God the more He become ignorable? Sometimes. I'm glad it isn't always.

Deep down inside I think God owes me something because I do a few devotions. Like God should be impressed because I showed up for adoration and give me some kind of vision. Instead He gives me the gift of being able to believe having not seen a vision. We walk by faith and not by sight. That is not a sad second choice. Faith is God's way because it is the best way. It gives us the dignity of choosing Him.

Then there is the idea of seeing God with the eyes of faith. When you know God has done great things in a certain situation but you also know someone without faith would not see it at all. Pope Benedict once said every theist is often uncomfortably on the edge of atheism and every atheist is often uncomfortably on the edge of theism. That we are always looking for something to close the deal. Something to keep our minds from ever going there. God just does not give that to us. Even if we get a vision we can question whether we made it up.

What keeps us from going over that edge? Love. Faith grows into hope and then into love.

Thursday, June 24, 2010

History and Carolyn Arends

Carolyn Arends is a singer who wrote something about church history. It is good to see protestants pay attention to church history. You will encounter God when you do. But encountering God is not always comfortable.
Hungry for context, I delved deeper—and soon realized why we don't share much church history with our kids. Yes, there are bright lights in the story. But there are also dark moments ...
Cardinal Newman says to be deep in history is to cease to be protestant. Arends' idea of deep is much shallower than Newman's idea of deep but it already has her understanding why most protestants don't go there. There are things that don't make any sense to a protestant. She calls the "dark moments" but the term is wrong. We are talking about things that continued uninterupted for centuries. Hardly a moment. Are they dark? If you buy into protestant thinking they are.

In so many ways church history is full of beautiful Christians but when it comes to sacraments or the authority of the pope they seem so dark. Actually they seem Catholic. How does that make any sense? Where are all the evangelicals?

Then there is another scary thought:
How do we process these stories? I open my Bible, and I recognize my debt to those who fought for the accessibility and authority of Scripture. My church holds a baptismal service, and I think of those who were drowned for claiming the right to be baptized as adults.

I recognize, too, that without dissenting voices, there would have been no Reformation. This tempers my response to fellow Christians whom I believe are doctrinally unorthodox. I disagree with them as my conscience dictates, but I must also respect them as potential sparks in a reforming fire. As long as the church is made up of humans, it will need reform, and reform will require dissent from the status quo.
Where have we gone here? Because I need to understand church history in the light of my protestant doctines I cannot see heresy and schism as bad things. If I must make those who rejected infant baptism as heros of the faith then how can I reject theological liberalism today? Arends is not a liberal and she would reject those ideas but she says here that such a rejection would run counter to what logically flows from her reading of history. So again we have a choice. Stop thinking deeply about history or stop thinking like a protestant. Guess which is easier? But God's way is often way harder. Still it is worth it.