Tuesday, June 22, 2010

Regensburg Revisited

After reflecting on the Muslim history I blogged about I decided to re-read the Regensburg talk from Sept 2006. The one thing that stands out is how it is not about Islam at all. He takes as a negative example the Muslims at Constantinople around the year 1400. But that is just one place and time where most would concede the Muslims behaved badly. They attacked Constantinople. They did it for the purpose of spreading the faith through the use of force.

His point was that the best defense against the spreading of faith through force is to point our the irrationality of it. His complaint is not so much against Muslims for being Muslim. It is against western scholars for excluding religion from their scholarship. That the wall that we have erected between faith and reason has done a great disservice to both sides. That the marriage of faith and reason that we see in Hellenized Christianity allows us to insist on a rational God and allows science to understand where it fits into the bigger picture. Here is a quote:

This gives rise to two principles which are crucial for the issue we have raised. First, only the kind of certainty resulting from the interplay of mathematical and empirical elements can be considered scientific. Anything that would claim to be science must be measured against this criterion. Hence the human sciences, such as history, psychology, sociology and philosophy, attempt to conform themselves to this canon of scientificity. A second point, which is important for our reflections, is that by its very nature this method excludes the question of God, making it appear an unscientific or pre-scientific question. Consequently, we are faced with a reduction of the radius of science and reason, one which needs to be questioned.

I will return to this problem later. In the meantime, it must be observed that from this standpoint any attempt to maintain theology's claim to be "scientific" would end up reducing Christianity to a mere fragment of its former self. But we must say more: if science as a whole is this and this alone, then it is man himself who ends up being reduced, for the specifically human questions about our origin and destiny, the questions raised by religion and ethics, then have no place within the purview of collective reason as defined by "science", so understood, and must thus be relegated to the realm of the subjective. The subject then decides, on the basis of his experiences, what he considers tenable in matters of religion, and the subjective "conscience" becomes the sole arbiter of what is ethical. In this way, though, ethics and religion lose their power to create a community and become a completely personal matter. This is a dangerous state of affairs for humanity, as we see from the disturbing pathologies of religion and reason which necessarily erupt when reason is so reduced that questions of religion and ethics no longer concern it. Attempts to construct an ethic from the rules of evolution or from psychology and sociology, end up being simply inadequate.
So what he is saying is not so much that Islam is bad. It is. What he is saying is that Western Christianity is headed in the same direction as Islam. That the marriage between faith and reason is breaking down and we will get an irrational religion and science disconnected from meaning and purpose. If you see theology as the queen of the sciences then the whole world is open to the rational mind. If you make logic and empirical observation the queen of the sciences then you either have to make the humanities fit or exclude them from scholarship. You end up not only losing theology but losing the hard sciences as well.

There is a reason why christian scientists are so devoted to their pursuit of the truth. Even if they are not very good Christians they often have enough of the christian world and life view that they believe in an ordered creation. They believe in the inherent good of learning about that order. It is really a desire for God even though many would not use that word.

Doctrine Matters

There is a theory that doctrine does not matter that much. That religion is simply man's way of connecting with his moral self and different religions do it slightly differently but those details are unimportant. Ironically that is a statement about doctrine and it does matter. It causes the secular world to be very confused by much human behaviour because they refuse to take into account the religious beliefs of the people involved as primary motivators for their behaviour. Those who do actually act on their belief are called radicals. Pope Benedict and Osama Bin Laden are both in this category because their behaviour cannot be understood without seriously considering their religion. Obviously no self-respecting intellectual can do that so it is best to just think of them as unenlightened people who behave erratically.

This struck me as I was listening to this especially a section on Muslim history. He talked about Mohammad breaking moral laws and rather than defending his actions with any kind of moral reasoning he simply said it was God's will. In one case he broke a cease-fire and attacked convoys during a holy month. He was a brutally violent man but many religious leaders were back then. This made him worse than any of them by breaking the annual time of peace everyone else was respecting. So he said it was God's will. But he didn't feel the need to explain why God was not evil for giving Mohammad such evil commands. Christian leaders would feel that need. God's revelation should not contradict what we know to be right and wrong. Mohammad believed God did not have to avoid contradicting Himself. He could command anything anytime and was above rational scrutiny.

Similarly when Mohammad wanted to marry his daughter-in-law. Again he claimed God told him that he should do it. Another objectively immoral act that God willed for no reason. It has profound effects on the way Muslim's think about God versus the way Christians think about God. The Christian God can be surprising but He is always surprising in a beautiful and loving way. He is never surprising in an arbitrary and evil way that Muslim's believe he can be.

So if young men are told it is God's will for them to strap explosives to themselves and blow themselves up in a crowd of people then this difference is huge. Christians could discern that God would never command such a brutal killing of innocents. Muslims cannot know that. There is nothing in their understanding of God that excludes it. Does that mean any Muslim would do that? No. They do have the option of questioning their leader and deciding he does not speak for God after all.

But what about all the bad acts by Christians over the centuries? They do exist. But there are degrees of morality. You cannot say that nobody is perfect therefore Hitler and Gandhi are pretty much on the same moral level. It does not follow. You need to talk about the number and kind of sins committed. There is also the notion of development. Christians have come to realize that executing heretics is immoral. Muslims have not even come to recognize killing random people is immoral. They can't. Every moral principle has to have this gigantic loophole of "unless it is God's will."

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Counter Factual Conditionals

Ryan over at CtC makes a comment:
The person who believes ‘once-saved-always-saved’ must believe that the warning passages are counter-factual conditionals. I’ll explain those terms (in case you’re not familiar w/them). A counterfactual asserts that some statement is true, where that statement describes something that isn’t the case (or won’t be the case). For example, ‘if I wasn’t writing this comment, I would be doing something else.’ A conditional is an ‘if..then…’ statement. So a counter-factual conditional statement, is an if-then statement about would would happen if something else happened.

The best way for the person who believes ‘once-saved-always-saved’ to interpret the warning passages is as a counter-factual conditional statement. In other words, the warnings would be interpreted as making a claim about what would happen if one apostatized. So they are true statements; if one apostatized, then x occurs. It’s just that they are counter-factual because the believer won’t apostatize (per the once-saved-always-saved view). It’s not that it’s somehow *impossible* for the believer to apostatize. It’s just that the true believer won’t do so.
I think this is a bit to simple. If a conditional is contrary to empirical fact that is very different than making a conditional based on an impossible premise.

If McCain had won the election then he would appoint pro-life judges.
That is a counter-factual conditional based on a possible premise. It is always going to be true in the trivial sense because the if condition didn't happen. But there is a sense in which this could be false. McCain could say he would not have appointed pro-life judges. That would not make it false in the strict logical sense but the statement is trying to convey something beyond the strict logic. That something could be true or false. If it is false then calling the statement true is quite perverse.

If the holocaust was a hoax then the Jews have a lot of explaining to do
That is a counter-factual conditional based on an impossible premise. So it logically true. But it is offensive. Why? Because making such a statement seems to imply the possibility that the if clause might be true. It does not say it but it implies it.

 So when a passage of scripture says "if one apostatized, then x occurs" the Calvinist cannot escape by just saying the statement is trivially true because the if clause is false. There is an implication that this case can happen. If that is not the case it should be made clear that this is a pure hypothetical. Like Paul talking about "if Christ was not raised ...". He makes clear that he does not think this possibility is real. If he did not it would be a very perverse way of speaking.

Now if you only claim scripture is inerrant you can use this tactic to get around these passages. But if you claim scripture is inspired or God-breathed you have a problem. Inerrant simply claims no errors. It can be unclear. It can be a deeply flawed way of expressing an idea. That is all consistent with inerrant.

Inspired means God is the author. It should not be perverse. It should not be misleading. It should not be confusing. That is a much stronger statement than inerrant. Counter-factual conditionals where the if clause is absolutely impossible should not appear in something with God as it's principle author. It would mean God is implying falsehood without technically speaking falsely. It means God speaks like Bill Clinton and hides behind what the word "is" could possibly mean.

Catholics can do this with infallible documents because they don't claim they are inspired. They are merely protected from error. They could contain misleading statements. They just cannot contain false statements. They cannot do it with scripture. Scripture is something we need to be constantly reading and contemplating. It does not obfuscate simple truths. It gives insight into great mysteries.

Talking About Sex

The Christopher West controversy is on again. West is taking a sabbatical. Dawn Eden has taken same shots while he is gone. Marcel from Mary's Aggies has responded in his absence. I think a lot of what is behind all the critique of West is his style. The content is mostly quite orthodox. He opposes contraception, premarital sex, gay marriage, masturbation, pornography, female ordination, etc. So why does he get so much heat from conservative Catholics? It has to do with the way he talks about these matters.

Look at any news story about anything related to sex. What happens? The story tries to exploit sex as it talks about sex. It tries to be pornographic while still having the guise of news. People want the titillation of sexual talk and sexual pictures without the guilt of watching something clearly pornographic. News shows get ratings when they do such sexual pseudo-news so they do a lot of it. Look at any major news website and you will see a few stories that have very little news value but give an excuse for injecting some smut into the show.

A good example of this was Nightline's piece on Christopher West. ABC didn't think it's viewers would be interested in a new development in Catholic theology. They thought people would watch because it was about sex. But West plays that game too. He mentions pop culture icons like Hugh Hefner and tries to do it in a shocking way. He explains it so that what he is saying is Catholic but the initial hook is designed to appeal to our baser instincts. It is not to surprising that ABC did not make all the right distinctions. They summarized his position by saying Hugh Hefner was one of his heroes. He claims he never said that and I believe him. But a comment like that is to much for a reporter to resist in this kind of a piece.

I am not saying the bulk of what West says has this problem. Every now and then he crosses a line. It bothers people. It causes them to view their entire message with extreme suspicion. It is a message they really should embrace. The church needs the laity to understand and defend Catholic sexual morality. He has done more to help with that then anybody I know over the last 13 years. He has made mistakes but I would say they are fewer and further between than most people who teach on the topic.

One of the unfortunate effects of getting people excited about Theology of the Body is they share what they have learned before they have really understood what is being taught. They often get it wrong. The line that West crosses once in a while they go way over. They have an immodesty to their sexual talk and they give West full credit. We need to rejoice in the good that has been done and help them to mature in that area as well. We do not need to write off the whole thing as evil. I mean they are following a teacher approved by bishops using material written by a pope. They could do worse. They could do a lot worse.

Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Obama and Catholic Unity

The American Papist offers some opinions on Obama's strategy with regards to Catholics and what it means for the Catholic Church in the US. Here is a quote:
To provide a couple brief parallel (and purely hypothetical) examples, what if Obama sent a message to a group of orthodox jews who violate kosher laws and praised them for supporting his domestic initiative of promoting American pork consumption?


Or again, what if Obama sent a message to a group of Jehova’s Witnesses who practice blood transfusions and thanked them for their support of National Donate Blood Day?

In both these hypothetical cases, Obama is praising “political” actions with deep religious connotations that, when chosen by those who claim to practice each faith, violate what it has traditionally meant to be Jewish or a Jehovah’s Witness.
I can see his point. I just don't think his conclusion is justified. Obama may be trying to split Catholics. The fact is he is doing the opposite. The way to Catholic unity is not enforcing good behaviour. It is in challenging dissenting Catholics to return to the fullness of the faith of leave. Don't be luke warm. Be hot or cold. With the strong divide between Obama and the bishops we are getting exactly this challenge.

It was not long ago when Democrats could count on the support of most Catholic bishops. During the health care debate Obama didn't even try and reach out to them. He counted them as strong opponents. Instead he reached out to Sr. Carol Keehan. This is common in church history. Catholics have to choose between their bishops and their king. It is good that people have to make a stand. It forces them to reflect on who they trust. Do they trust the wisdom of God or the wisdom of man. Often the stark choices lead to better decisions. If we think it a small matter than we tend to indulge the world more. If the matter is obviously very serious we have a harder time justifying opposing the church. So the more battles Obama has with the bishops I think the better it will be for the church. It will lose some members but the ones that stay will be so much stronger.

Development of Doctrine and Baptismal Regeneration

Getting back to the idea of Development of Doctrine. It is a complex argument with multiple threads and many points where someone might challenge you. Still when you grasp the whole of it there is a sense of awe. One thread is being discussed at CtC. It has to do with baptismal regeneration. The pattern is always the same. The argument is to show that a particular doctrine is a corruption of historical Christian teaching. That is to say the reformed teaching on baptism cannot be reconciled with the belief of the church at a certain time in history. Bryan Cross puts it this way:
According to PCA pastor Wes White, the doctrine of baptismal regeneration is “impossible in the Reformed system.” By noting this, he intends to show that we should reject the doctrine of baptismal regeneration. But if the evidence for the truth of the doctrine of baptismal regeneration is stronger than the evidence for the truth of the “Reformed system,” then the incompatibility of the doctrine of baptismal regeneration and the Reformed system serves as evidence against the Reformed system.
Dr Cross does a good job of finding quotes from many early church fathers showing they did believe the doctrine of baptismal regeneration. There is some work to do here because protestants have an amazing capacity to avoid some of the most obvious truths about the early church fathers.

But Newman goes further than this. He finds that showing protestant Christianity in any of it's forms is different from historical Christianity is the easy part. Protestants often fail to contemplate the significance of that. Just like they fail to ask how they can know they have the right flavor of "biblical" Christianity. It is just as easy not to ask if Christianity was wrong once why can't it be wrong now? But to the extent they do think about these questions the answer is mostly a response of, "Sure there are problems but I believe in Jesus and this is the best I can do as far as doctrine goes."

Newman tackles that question. Is there really no Christian faith that can say it has never been corrupted?  If that were true it would be a pretty good reason to doubt the divinity of Jesus. Why did He allow His gospel to become such a mess? If the gospel really is the power of God for our salvation then would God not want to preserve it?

Now, in the simplest form, the question of has the Catholic faith or the Orthodox faith changed since the time of the early church has to be answered with a Yes. Certainly the council of Nicaea changed the faith. It clarified the doctrine of the trinity. But clarifying is not a problem. Even teaching a deep and fuller version of the same doctrine is not a problem. We get a problem only when it becomes impossible to hold that the previous teaching was right. Paul never corrupted the teaching of Jesus because it is possible to hold they were both teaching truth. Nicaea never corrupted the teaching of the New Testament for the same reason.

Newman called these changes that don't corrupt the faith "developments". So the question Newman asked could be phrased as:
Can any Christian faith be understood as an unbroken series of developments from the time of Christ to the present?
Now Newman knew there would be some subjective judgements involved in answering this question. But he wanted to keep that to a minimum. So he introduced a series of criteria or notes to more objectively determine what is a corruption and what is a development. Things get quite complicated from there. But if you understand the difference between a corruption and a development you can remove a lot of the complexity.

So the attack on protestantism is not enough. Protestants are used to having their beliefs attacked. What is needed is to show the Catholic faith passes the test that you would expect the true faith to pass. That is the test of non-contradiction.

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

70's Nostalgia

Ross Douthat has pointed out some people seeming to be pining for the sexual climate of the 1970's.  That was when the sexual revolution was exciting. Everything was new and shocking. Sin is like that. It is basically a lie. You can believe the lie for a while but eventually the truth becomes plain. It reminds me of my kids playing with toys. They make a mess. They don't clean it up. Works great. Then you have to live in a mess. But if life is already a mess then you can't find any joy in more messing. In fact, it is hard to enjoy much of anything. Eventually you might see the wisdom of keeping the house neat and tidy. Or maybe you just pine for the time when you created that first mess and had so much fun.

There is an idea the sexual revolution has gone too far but the solution is no to undo it completely. That the expectation people would remain a virgin until marriage was just to extreme. That somehow we can retain the sacredness of sex without actually expecting self-control. It comes out of a muddled thinking. There is not a clear idea of what is the goal of sexual morality. Is it there just to add some spice to life when you break the rules? Why does it exist? The writers sense something has gone dreadfully wrong in this area. They just can't really analyze what it is.

The problem is they start at the wrong point. They start with sex. It is hard to make sense of why you would want any rules if your focus is on the physical pleasure of sexual stimulation. Where they need to start is not with sex but with procreation. The question people need to ask is not who do I want to have fun with but who do I want to raise a family with. Then the idea of marrying a virgin seems to make more sense.